Naval History Forums

The tactical situation as it transpired on the 24th, would have precluded any chance at crossing the German "T" unless the Germans themselves chose to execute some maneuver to enable it that to occur, which was unlikely, as the Germans had little to gain in a ship-to-ship shootout, especially in a t...

While it's possible that Hood jettisoned torpedoes, that's unlikely, particularly since we found one close to the main hull section in the debris field. I am unaware of any film of the wreck showing '... part of the bow... with just the stern remaining...' as you mentioned. So far as I know there is...

That's true. The relationship between wear rate and initial velocity is extremely complex, depending upon the design of the driving band(s), projectile seating, gun caliber, propellant chemistry, and rate-of-fire, and usually must be treated on a case-by-case basis. In VERY rough terms, the followin...

Another good question. Probably because the additional wear and tear on the gun and mounting didn't justify the advantage except in unusual circumstances. To begin with, it's more difficult to design supercharges as they tend to be smaller in size than regular bag loads, i.e. for a five bag load, go...

Good questions. Generally, the chamber is not filled completely. Even if one crammed the bags in by force, there would still be considerable 'empty' volume left, as (for example) single perforated grains -- basically thick tubes -- still leave the entire internal volume of the grain, and the space b...

A few quick observations: There is little advantage to improved tube stiffness except at very short ranges. At longer ranges, it hardly matters at all. So far as weight vs caliber is concerned, it's safe -- as a rule of thumb -- to assume that weight is proportional to the cube of the caliber. It's ...

It's very difficult to say. I am skeptical that any convincing case can be made regarding the detailed effects of the explosion re venting, etc., as such phenomena are rarely, if ever, tested full size, and we actually know quite little about the precise explosion point, etc. It is very difficult to...

The continued references, by a variety of parties, to relatively light high-velocity projectiles vs relatively heavy low velocity projectiles is interesting to me insofar as simple ballistic analysis will quickly show that at ANY range for equivalent initial energies delivered at the muzzle, the res...

My thanks to Wadinga for his kind comments re INRO and Warship International. Paul Mercer wrote: "[Regarding the relative effects of a one ton bomb against a one ton shell, if I am correct in my understanding of the replies [to a previous question] the answer being that a shell would be falling at a...

There are a number of rule-of-thumb formulas for this. At normal battle ranges, these allow doing the problem in one's head. For 9 guns and U.S. guns, expected pattern size is range is typically around 1.8-2.0% of range. At long ranges where gun alignment doesn't really matter much, provided the int...

Yes. Bill Garzke is a close friend of mine, so I have had a copy of this book for years now. It is a nice treatment, and it's likely that I actually helped in completing parts of it. Memory fails...

Bill Jurens

Often, small salvos were used because it made spotting more difficult -- it's harder to accurately spot a four-gun pattern than a nine-gun pattern, and the target practices were often for training purposes. Sometimes shorter ranges were employed with reduced charges, which essentially made a 24000 y...

Thanks, Thorsten. I remain, very respectfully, skeptical...

Bill Jurens

A few posts ago, Wadinga wrote: "... those very few, unusually-long range hits you cited were only possible in the stern chase situation, ie small rate of change of both azimuth and distance and easily-estimated inclination." I'd have to disagree. Actually, until very late in the fire control develo...

Although he and I often disagreed on various points, I invariably found him to be a cooperative, honest, reasonable, and knowledgeable opponent when we disagreed, and a patient and generous source of information when we did not. I tip my hat to a man who made some fine and useful contributions to th...