Hello everybody,
@ Dunmunro,
few considerations reading thru the 2 parts posted :
1) Hood and PoW were supposed to engage the enemy with 2 or 3 cruisers, there was a " general Plan " according to the Admiralty.
2) PoW retreating did cause a " sharp disappointment " to Churchill.
3) Norfolk and Suffolk shadowed -> It is incorrect ! Only Suffolk did it. The statement " their signals " should not be there, given the enourmous difference in shadowing and sending radio signals between the 2 heavy cruisers.
4) Hood open fire time is correct at 05.52 ( in reality 05.52 and 30 secs ), there is no open fire listed for the German warships, we know from the German documents and the Admiralty ( Royal Navy Admiralty Battle Summary Nr. 5 last version on 1948 ) that it happened 2/3 minutes after at 05.55.
5) Hood explosion time is correct at 06.00, according to almost all the available reports and documents both sides.
6) The PoW under fire, cause of retreat and damages are a mix between Tovey dispatches and the Admiralty minute of September 1941, they do not correspond to the event correct sequence, since PoW started her retreat before having received the majority of the hits, ... and there is no mention to the Y quadruple turret jamming ...
... we know why it is like that.
7) Churchill obviously felt also the need to justify RearAdm Wake-Walker decision not to re-engagé the enemy with PoW and 2 heavy cruisers, and we know why as well. The fact that PoW was considered not being a match for the Bismarck is particularly important. Never after DS and May 27th, ... so the Bismarck experience and chase, ... a KGV class battleship was going to be considered to engage the Tirpitz one on one. At least 2 KGV class warships were needed, or better one KGV class jointly with a 16 inch US Navy fast battleship.
8) To hold the enemy " under observation " is a very unusual statement to be read, but we know how that was done from a " comfortable safe distance " and we know the final result of that very careful effort, resulting on the lost of the enemy while into a very critical convoys area on that moment, ... with a special reference to the convoy W.S. 8B with 40.000 British soldiers.
Bye Antonio