The Dreadnought Challenge!
Posted: Mon Jun 05, 2006 5:21 pm
Hey guys:
let´s figure this out: HMS Dreadnought vs. IJN Satsuma vs. USS South Carolina. The three "firsts" challenging between them. If we study their specifications they were all quite "standard" having more or less the same displacement, armour, armament and speed. The Japanese had a handicap because they weren´t able to install all 12" guns as they planned and had to use some 10". So there´s something about a congressional mandante (ergo: illlogic. Why is it that politicians always try to weaken their own countries in order that, when in war, the cost of lives increase because of that same weakness?) limiting the South Carolina.
Let´s see them:
I. Important Dates: Desgined or Ordered, Laid down, Launched
HMS Dreadnought: 1905, 1905, 1906
IJN Satsuma:1904,1905, 1906
USS South Carolina: 1905, 1906, 1908
II. Displacement:
HMS Dreadnought: 18,420 tons
IJN Satsuma: 19,372 tons std/ 19,700 tons full
USS South Carolina: 16,000 tons/17,900 tons
III. Dimensions: lenght, beam, draught
HMS Dreadnought: 160.55 mts, 24.98 mts, 7.92 mts
IJN Satsuma: 146.91 mts, 25.5 mts, 8.38 mts.
USS South Carolina: 137.85 mts, 24.43 mts, 7.46 mts.
IV. Horsepower & speed
HMS Dreadnought: 22,500 hp @ 21 knots
IJN Satsuma: 17,300 hp @ 18.5 knots
USS South Carolina: 16,500 hp @ 18.86 knots
V. Armament: main, Secondary1, Secondary2, torpedoes
HMS Dreadnought: 8 x 12" cal 45, 27 x 12 pounders (4"), 5 x 18" torpedoes.
IJN Satsuma: 2 x 12" + 12 x 10" (projected 14 x 12": 6 more than Dreadnought), 12 x 4.7", 4 x 3", 5 x 18" torpedoes.
USS South Carolina: 8 x 12", 22 x 3". 2 x 3 `pounders, 2 x 21" torpedoes
VI. Armour:
HMS Dreadnought: 11" main belt
IJN Satsuma:9" main belt
USS South Carolina: 12" main belt
Huh? Pretty close isn´t it? Well: what do you think?
let´s figure this out: HMS Dreadnought vs. IJN Satsuma vs. USS South Carolina. The three "firsts" challenging between them. If we study their specifications they were all quite "standard" having more or less the same displacement, armour, armament and speed. The Japanese had a handicap because they weren´t able to install all 12" guns as they planned and had to use some 10". So there´s something about a congressional mandante (ergo: illlogic. Why is it that politicians always try to weaken their own countries in order that, when in war, the cost of lives increase because of that same weakness?) limiting the South Carolina.
Let´s see them:
I. Important Dates: Desgined or Ordered, Laid down, Launched
HMS Dreadnought: 1905, 1905, 1906
IJN Satsuma:1904,1905, 1906
USS South Carolina: 1905, 1906, 1908
II. Displacement:
HMS Dreadnought: 18,420 tons
IJN Satsuma: 19,372 tons std/ 19,700 tons full
USS South Carolina: 16,000 tons/17,900 tons
III. Dimensions: lenght, beam, draught
HMS Dreadnought: 160.55 mts, 24.98 mts, 7.92 mts
IJN Satsuma: 146.91 mts, 25.5 mts, 8.38 mts.
USS South Carolina: 137.85 mts, 24.43 mts, 7.46 mts.
IV. Horsepower & speed
HMS Dreadnought: 22,500 hp @ 21 knots
IJN Satsuma: 17,300 hp @ 18.5 knots
USS South Carolina: 16,500 hp @ 18.86 knots
V. Armament: main, Secondary1, Secondary2, torpedoes
HMS Dreadnought: 8 x 12" cal 45, 27 x 12 pounders (4"), 5 x 18" torpedoes.
IJN Satsuma: 2 x 12" + 12 x 10" (projected 14 x 12": 6 more than Dreadnought), 12 x 4.7", 4 x 3", 5 x 18" torpedoes.
USS South Carolina: 8 x 12", 22 x 3". 2 x 3 `pounders, 2 x 21" torpedoes
VI. Armour:
HMS Dreadnought: 11" main belt
IJN Satsuma:9" main belt
USS South Carolina: 12" main belt
Huh? Pretty close isn´t it? Well: what do you think?