paulcadogan wrote:So 3 cruisers covering 400 km of ocean - what was the probability that, had Bismarck & PG come through their patrol area, ANY of them would have made contact, and even if they had, that they could maintain it. ...........
Another factor might have been the weather - but even in relatively clear conditions, it seems workable to me.
Dave Saxton wrote:The Germans, with Hipper, Scheer, Deutschland, Scharnhorst and Gneisenau,and hilfkruezers
paulcadogan wrote:No Dave!
Scheer, Hipper and G & S all entered the Atlantic via the Denmark Strait. The twins did so after their near encounter with the Home Fleet in the I-F gap..........
Same for several of the hilfskreuzers. Altantis, Widder, Kormoran, Pinguin, Thor (and it seems Orion) ALL used the DS to break out. ..
alecsandros wrote:The Admiralty was informed of the 2 ships leaving Bergen on May 20th, and air patrols from Coastal Command and RAF were intensified.
Dave Saxton wrote:Passing through these passages undetected was the norm rather than the exception. The Germans, with Hipper, Scheer, Deutschland, Scharnhorst and Gneisenau, and hilfkruezers, and supply ships, routinely did it; often encountering RN cruisers that remained unaware of the Germans or were unable to retain contact. The only exception was the historical Bismarck passage because of the Suffolk's Type 284 radar. So the odds are well in Luetjens favor that he will make an undetected break out, considering that the patrolling cruisers will not be operating a capable radar and they must cover such a wide expanse of ocean.
Patrol aircraft did not alter the outcomes of all these other passages. It is rare indeed that visibility will be good.
Dave Saxton wrote:Retaining contact long enough to bring the Home Fleet battle groups in is the main problem for the British as I see it. Catching a glimpse of the enemy is one thing, but shadowing for hours on end is quite another. Unless there are prolonged periods of unlimited visibility- rather unlikely-it seems a difficult task without capable surface search radar. For example, when the Scharnhorst and Gneisenau tried the Gap previously they were spotted by a British cruiser briefly. The cruiser was unable to retain contact. It reported that it had seen the Hipper. The Germans will know by local radio intercepts if they were being shadowed or not as they did historically.
When the Scheer came back through the Denmark Strait in March of 41 its radar warned it of an approaching patrol in time to duct into a near by fog. This was a daylight encounter. They watched the British cruiser steam by. The British look outs never saw the Scheer. A second encounter came at night. In this case the Scheer's radar was not operating because the moisture resistant cases had been carelessly not closed up. The Scheer suddenly found it self in the wake of an enemy cruiser no more than 3,000 meters away on a bright star lit night. But once again the British look outs never saw the Scheer. This was in the Denmark Strait so the Germans really had no where to go. Such were the difficulties faced by the British patrols in any of the northern passages.
As Mr Raven points out, Enigma Intel will be available after the 29th due to the capture of Enigma keys from U-110 and the weather ships. The British could use Ultra Intel to help find Luetjens once out in the Atlantic by the arrangement of meeting of supply ships. The keys were not those used by surface warships in distant waters, but Prinz Eugen will need frequent re-fueling. The British will need to be careful in the use of this Intel so that the Germans don't become wise to it and change the keys.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests